Skip to main content

What are the differences between synchronized method and synchronized block (statement)?

--
The synchronization is the capability to control the access of multiple threads to shared resources. Without synchronization, it is possible for one thread to modify a shared resource while another thread is in the process of using or updating that resource.

There two synchronization syntax in Java Language. The practical differences are in controlling scope and the monitor. With a synchronized method, the lock is obtained for the duration of the entire method. With synchronized blocks you can specify exactly when the lock is needed.

Basically, synchronized blocks are more general, and synchronized methods can be rewritten to use synchronized blocks:
class Program {
  public synchronized void f() {
   .........
  }
}
is equivalent to
class Program {
  public void f() {
     synchronized(this){
       ...
     }
  }
}
For example, You have a method with some parts that need synchronized and others don't. The synchronized block lets you synchronize only the partial line codes that really need it.
public class Program {
  private static Object locker1 = new Object();
  private static Object locker1 = new Object();
  public void doSomething1() {
    ...
    synchronized(locker1) {
      ......... //do something protected;
    }
    ....
  }
  public void doSomething2() {
    ...
    synchronized(locker2) {
      ......... //do something protected;
    }
    ....
  }
}
The synchronized block can only be executed after a thread has acquired the lock for the object or class referenced, for example the "locker1" or "locker2" in above code, in the synchronized statement.

The above code shows that synchronized block can be holding different object monitors. Maybe it's necessary to protect doSomething1() method and doSomething2() method from multiple threads, but it's fine if one thread is in the doSomething1() method and another is in the doSomething2() method. But the synchronized method can not do it.

A synchronized method synchronizes on the object instance or the class. A thread only executes a synchronized method after it has acquired the lock for the method's object or class.
  • static synchronized methods synchronize on the class object. If one thread is executing a static synchronized method, all other threads trying to execute any static synchronized methods, in the same class, will block.
  • non-static synchronized methods synchronize on "this" (the instance object). If one thread is executing a synchronized method, all other threads trying to execute any synchronized methods, in the same class, will block.
These are very public monitors, meaning some other thread could synchronize on them for the wrong reason, leading to slowdowns or deadlocks.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Asynchronous Vs. Synchronous Communications

Synchronous (One thread):   1 thread -> |<---A---->||<----B---------->||<------C----->| Synchronous (multi-threaded):   thread A -> |<---A---->| \ thread B ------------> ->|<----B---------->| \ thread C ----------------------------------> ->|<------C----->|

WebSphere MQ Interview Questions

What is MQ and what does it do? Ans. MQ stands for MESSAGE QUEUEING. WebSphere MQ allows application programs to use message queuing to participate in message-driven processing. Application programs can communicate across different platforms by using the appropriate message queuing software products. What is Message driven process? Ans . When messages arrive on a queue, they can automatically start an application using triggering. If necessary, the applications can be stopped when the message (or messages) have been processed. What are advantages of the MQ? Ans. 1. Integration. 2. Asynchrony 3. Assured Delivery 4. Scalability. How does it support the Integration? Ans. Because the MQ is independent of the Operating System you use i.e. it may be Windows, Solaris,AIX.It is independent of the protocol (i.e. TCP/IP, LU6.2, SNA, NetBIOS, UDP).It is not required that both the sender and receiver should be running on the same platform What is Asynchrony? Ans. With messag

Advantages & Disadvantages of Synchronous / Asynchronous Communications?

  Asynchronous Communication Advantages: Requests need not be targeted to specific server. Service need not be available when request is made. No blocking, so resources could be freed.  Could use connectionless protocol Disadvantages: Response times are unpredictable. Error handling usually more complex.  Usually requires connection-oriented protocol.  Harder to design apps Synchronous Communication Advantages: Easy to program Outcome is known immediately  Error recovery easier (usually)  Better real-time response (usually) Disadvantages: Service must be up and ready. Requestor blocks, held resources are “tied up”.  Usually requires connection-oriented protocol